Thursday, October 21, 2010

The Miracle (I Miracolo). 1948. Directed by Roberto Rosselini.

(5/21/01)

I am sure that I didn't get what this film is all about. A peasant woman, considered crazy by her neighbors, meets a shepherd on a hillside. She is convinced that he is St. Joseph and wants him to take her to heaven with him. It's an interesting beginning for a film, but it is bizarre because the woman does this lengthy monologue, talking on and on while the shepherd just sits looking at her and not saying a word. Why? What does that mean? The woman is played by Anna Magnani and the situation certainly gives her an excuse to perform, but that doesn't really explain it.

The next thing we know the woman is pregnant and convinced that the child she is carrying is Jesus Christ. This is interesting in that Saint Joseph really wasn't the father of Jesus who was immaculately conceived. Does that mean something?

Anyway, the woman is scorned by her neighbors and leaves the village and wanders around--and wanders and wanders. There is just a lot of footage of her wandering. Finally, in a cave she has her child and the picture ends.

Magnani is interesting to watch and the whole film has the raw, earthy quality that we associate with neo-realism. The only thing I can find to say by way of interpretation is that the film is about the need we all have--which can become desperate--to feel important.

A Difficult Life (Una vita difficile). 1961. Directed by Dino Risi.

(5/21/01)

This film, too, was shown without subtitles. I had no idea what it was all about, but it looked like a pretty interesting film. A lot went on in it. Alberto Sordi had a presence about him and it was a pleasure to see Lea Masari again. (I only know her from L'Avventura.)

One scene made an impression on me. Masari is Sordi's wife or ex-wife and she seems to have rejected him. She is out with some people and he follows her into an outdoor nightclub and makes a fool of himself. They leave and he follows them into the street. It is dawn and I think he attacks the car and it drives off leaving him alone on that deserted street with just the bouncer of the club looking at him. Something like that. I may have the details wrong, but it was an interesting scene.

At the end Sordi pushes a man who seems like a boss or a rich client into a swimming pool, thereby rejecting him and his money. That reminded me of Clark Gable pouring the water over Sydney Greenstreet's head in The Hucksters.

Four Steps in the Clouds (Quatro passi tra le nuvole). 1942. Directed by Alessandro Blasetti.

(5/21/01)

I was truly disappointed that this film was shown without subtitles. I had seen it in 1978 and, having enjoyed it, was looking forward to seeing it again.

It has an engaging, homely quality about it. A married salesman is persuaded by a young woman he meets on his travels to accompany her to her family's home and pretend to be her husband, as she is an unwed mother. Her father in particular seems to be a difficult man. The family searches the man's luggage and finds pictures of his wife and children which (I guess) suggest that he is a bigamist. He tells them the truth and it appears that this stranger who comes out of nowhere straightens out this dysfunctional family before returning to his humdrum existence.

I continue to like the character of the grandfather especially--the old man who plays checkers by himself, moving from one side of the table to the other. If I remember right he gets the salesman to use his samples of candies as the checkers and quickly eats a couple of themwhile the other man isn't looking.

The Adventures of Robin Hood. 1938. Directed by Michael Curtiz and William Keighley.

(5/21/01)

After all these years and all these viewings, Warners' Robin Hood remains one of my favorites. There is a freshness and a richness about it which I love. I don't know of a more beautiful film in color. It was as if Technicolor found its perfect subject in this film. The pagentry and spectacle of medieval England are just dazzling to behold. It conjuires up a whole world which probably never existed--but should have. It is a first-class job all the way.

And Technicolor was especially suited to this production because so much of Robin Hood takes place outdoors. The color brought Sherwood Forest vibrantly to life--as well as the archery contest and the near-hanging. The scene where Marian starts to warm up to Robin somehow seems more memorable for being set outdoors. And the cinematographers made excellent use of the locations to create striking images. One favorite of mine is when Robin escapes from the castle and we have the long shot of him riding down the hill on horseback.

Erich Wolfgang Korngold outdid himself with the music. Considered by some to be his greatest film score, it is undoubtedly his most colorful. It brings the film to life. And then there is all that wonderful dialogue, delightful still after repeated viewings.

And then there are the performances. This film has a gallery of vividly-drawn characters who really seem to belong in an old story that we enjoy listening to again and again. In some cases it seems as if the actors had found a perfect context for their screen personas. Was there ever a better use for Eugene Pallette's gruffness than as Friar Tuck? Well, I supposed he was used as well in It Happened One Night--but he still gives me the sense of having been destined by his maker to play Tuck. And wonderful Una O'Connor--I don't think that her talents ever found a better outlet. Her romance with Much--the miller's son who never had a sweetheart--is so endearing and adds so much.

I guess that the characters remind me of Chaucer's pilgrims--not least of all because of the medieval English setting. Also just right is Ian Hunter as Richard the Lion-Hearted. The moment when he reveals his identity to Robin and his men gives me goosebumps. If Hunter ever had a better moment on the screen I have yet to hear of it.

And then there is Claude Rains as Prince John. He is irresistable. I really think that this is my favorite Claude Rains performance, probably because he seems to be enjoying himself so thoroughly. And he has so much fun with the dialogue which, after all, was written to be enjoyed. And he makes it clear that, after all, he's not really hurting people and causing suffering; he's just there to be the obstacle that the hero needs to oppose. His performance reassures us that it's all in good fun.

And then we come to Errol Flynn. He never looked better. He's perhaps a little more poised than in Captain Blood and that green suit he wears is most becoming. He cuts a fine figure in Technicolor. He plays here not a hero but a legend. Olivia de Havilland is likewise enhanced by Technicolor. The two of them retain the chemistry that they had in that earlier film and go through the paces of an antagonism (here only on the woman's part) which is dissolved into love and admiration. It's an old story, but one the world never tires of.

I shouldn't fail to mention another of my favorite images in this film: the moments in the duel between Robin and Sir Guy of Gisborne when we see the shadows of the duellists against a gigantic column. That's the sort of bravura, larger-than-life touch with which this film abounds.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Sunrise. 1927. Directed by F. W. Murnau.

(5/14/01-5/21/01)

Sunrise is well-established as a classic. However, having seen it a number of times now I think I have to be honest and admit that I really don't like it that much. It's just not a favorite of mine. I wonder if I will ever learn to appreciate and love it, to really see what it is that other people admire about it.

I didn't like the way the film shifted gears. The first part is a stark piece about a man who is persuaded to kill his loyal wife so that he can be with another woman. At the last moment he discovers that he can't do it. This part of the film is executed withgrim seriousness. Then he has to win back his wife's trust. But then, with everything for the moment resolved, the film turns into a series of silly comic vignettes in the city. Husband and wife go to a photographer to have their picture taken and knock over a statue of the winged victory or Venus De Milo and think they've broken it. There is an episode at a carnival with a drunken pig after which (or maybe before which) they do the peasant dance. I suppose that it can be said that life is like this, but in the film it just doesn't work. For me. And when the storm comes at the end and we think that the wife has indeed drowned I just couldn't get interested. Maybe I was too tired.

Another problem was that I didn't find Janet Gaynor appealing or even interesting. She did nothing for me--to put it bluntly. On the other hand, I was quite impressed with the performance which Murnau got out of George O'Brien. He walks around like a zombie in the first part of the film when he is under the spell of the temptress from the city. (He pulls it off and it isn't laughable.) And then he is awkward and poignant as he tries to win his wife back. And he is touchingly ill-at-ease in the big city. Not bad for someone who is known primarily as a b-Western star.

The film does have its own special texture, its own special flavor. One thing I did like was the montage that illustrates night life in the city that the villainess describes to the man. This was very reminiscent of the European avant-garde of the twenties. And I vaguely rememberthat there was a sohisticated use of titles. I think that when the villainess suggests to the man that he kill jis wife the words seem to melt on the screen--or grow and become more emphatic--something like that.

The first part of the film is very different from the average American film--of the 20s or otherwise. Instead of having scenes that are acted out it unfolds in a series of what you might call living photographs. Or tableaus. Shots in which the participants are posed, but really don't do anything as people do in real life. It was very stylized.

I was tired when I saw it, but I have seen it on other occasions and Sunrise just isn't one of my favorites. As much as I admire its photography and set designs and so forth I really don't enter into it emotionally.

Between Two Worlds. 1944. Directed by Edward L. Blatt.

(5/14/01)

I have a feeling that this film might have seemed somewhat pretentious in 1944. On the other hand, it was made at a time when death was very much in the air and thus probably seemed timely. It has a sophisticated, a very modern look about it and seems quite appropriate for a score by Erich Wolfgang Korngold as a "modern" composer rather than a sound-illustrator for historical pagents.

While it has a seriousness about it, I don't think it can be taken seriously as a depiction of what happens after the breath leaves the body. It is affirmative in that the suicides (or the suicidal man, really) come to see the value of life and wish to return. And it is even more affirmative in that the powers that be allow him to, as they even allow John Garfield the chance (if I read it correctly) to change on the other side. The idea that you can still strive and learn and improve on the other side is a radical view--but a reassuring one. (I don't get why he can have another chance, but not the rich man nor the unfaithful wife. Ah, well. . .)

One of the real pleasures of Between Two Worlds is watching performers with such diverse acting styles--or maybe just diverse personalities. They are woven together like different melodies or different timbres into a kind of dramatic symphony. John Garfield (perhaps he overacts; I think he acts like a stage performer), Paul Henreid, George Tobias, Sydney Greenstreet, Sara Allgood and Edmund Gwenn--it is wonderful watching these people interact. I think I was most moved by George Tobias who thinks he is on his way home to see his new baby, though Sara Allgood is touching as is the minister who has decided to finally go out and see the world. Sydney Greenstreet strides into the film right when things need to be livened up--and liven them up he does. And Edmund Gwenn--a suicide who is condemned to sort of play ferryman forever and ever is--on second thought--probably just as poignant as George Tobias. His great moment is when he pleads with Sydney Greenstreet not to condemn the young woman to the same fate as he has known. Greenstreet doesn't answer him except to say, "good man" and walk down the stairs. But he does grant the kindly man's request.

Paul Henreid seems to overdo it a little bit as the suicide. That's how it seems, but I think the problem is that we don't have a chance to get to know him before he gets to the end of his rope. That's not his fault; it's just the way the film was laid out.

This is not a profound film; it may even be a cliched one. But it's very enjoyable.

And I did love George Tobias's good luck charm--a little doll he calls the Hohokus.

The Sea Hawk. 1940. Directed by Michael Curtiz.

(5/8/01)

The Sea Hawk looks more visually polished than Captain Blood but it is not as good a film. The main problem with it is that it's all politics. The film is about a struggle between England and Spain and we are told that England is the good side and Spain the bad. It doesn't have the level of human interest of Captain Blood which is a moving story about one man.

Errol Flynn struck me as somewhat stiff in this film as compared with Captain Blood. I had a sense of him as a professional instead of a heroic young man. (For some reason the word "professional" suggests detachment to me, a lack of passionate engagement.) He was less attractive, less earnest, less passionate, less gallant. It was like he was already starting to lose interest.

Brenda Marshall did not have the sparkle of Olivia de Havilland in her films with Flynn. There was no real excitement in their scenes together, even though she was initially resistant to him. And Claude Rains was wasted in an uninteresting role.

There is not much atmosphere or sense of place. At least, not any that you would take home with you. I did like Korngold's exotic music for the tropical locale, but that was about it. It is really a straightforward action picture.

It doesn't have the comic accents of Captain Blood. The monkey running around the palace with the nightcap on his head just seemed silly. I did enjoy Flora Robson's Queen Elizabeth after watching Bette Davis's flamboyant portrayal the week before.

This film is highly regarded--at least it was by the authors of The Films of Errol Flynn--but I was disappointed in it. But perhaps it only suffers by contrast with Captain Blood. Seen by itself it might have been an enjoyable experience.